Choosing the right dog. Protecting children... German Shepherd or collie?

by Mike Biehler
(Edson Alberta, Canada)

We live on the edge of town on five treed acres. We are often visited by deer and moose and this year by a cougar. Our children are aged 3,5 & 7. Since the cougar siting we are afraid to let the kids play in our yard. We need a dog.

A german shepherd seems like the right dog because it is territorial, vigilant and protective. But our last dog, a shepherd cross, was inclined to be too aggressive toward visitors. We did not make him aggressive, he was the most pampered dog you could imagine. He just had a deeply inbred suspicion of strangers.

We're afraid that a pure bred will be even more inclined toward aggression. Should we buy a collie because it is so child friendly? Or can you tell me how to buy a gentle shepherd?

The new dog, will be an outside dog, but he will live in dog heaven. He will be free to roam in a huge yard which is surrounded by an invisible fence and he will get plenty of attention from the kids and from two adults who jog or ski almost every day.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to GSD Questions Form.

Sign up for promotions, news, discounts, and the chance to win prizes for you and your German Shepherd

E-mail Address
First Name

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you German Shepherds Rule.

300 x 250

Thank you for this web site. Very informative and well written. I often advise my shepherd people to visit here for information. Again GREAT JOB.
Laura Page Warden

What a fabulous website!!! I really enjoyed reading about the history of the dogs. There is a ton of helpful information on here and defiantly something for every reader to enjoy!!!
Misty Weaver

Recently got a GSD again. Last time had GSD no internet etc. Cant believe how much info for free. Kenneth

I love and appreciate the helpful advice I found on your website!